|
Yield Comparison of Bt- and
nonBt-corn in year 2000 by Missouri University Trial. |
|
||||||||
|
（ミズーリ州立大学の栽培試験結果を 河田が整理したもの） |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Planting
Place |
|
|
|||||
|
Brand-Hybrid Name |
Bt
resist |
Mat
G |
Corning |
Albany |
Osborn |
Novelty |
LaGrande |
Brand-Hybrid total |
Brand-Hybrid
Mean |
|
Burrus 440 |
no |
1 |
141 |
139.5 |
180 |
213.6 |
202.7 |
876.8 |
175.4 |
|
Croplan Genetics 661 |
no |
1 |
131.5 |
135.2 |
155.7 |
200.4 |
189.4 |
812.2 |
162.4 |
|
Freedom 5503 |
no |
1 |
139.6 |
86.6 |
172.5 |
206.4 |
171.4 |
776.5 |
155.3 |
|
Lewis 5450 |
no |
1 |
122.8 |
127 |
165.1 |
203.8 |
185.5 |
804.2 |
160.8 |
|
Novartis N65-A1 |
no |
1 |
146.5 |
130.8 |
171.3 |
198.7 |
184.9 |
832.2 |
166.4 |
|
Pioneer hybrid 34B23 |
no |
1 |
138 |
134.1 |
140.8 |
184.3 |
167.1 |
764.3 |
152.9 |
|
AgVenture AV813 |
no |
2 |
155.6 |
123.6 |
183.1 |
212.2 |
189.1 |
863.6 |
172.7 |
|
Asgrow RX740 |
no |
2 |
145.9 |
127.8 |
176.9 |
201.9 |
185.8 |
838.3 |
167.7 |
|
Asgrow RX764 |
no |
2 |
126 |
121.8 |
150.6 |
192.5 |
164.6 |
755.5 |
151.1 |
|
Burrus 569 |
no |
2 |
150.4 |
131.7 |
183 |
219.5 |
199.9 |
884.5 |
176.9 |
|
Burrus 622 |
no |
2 |
151.2 |
116.2 |
164.8 |
203.4 |
181.4 |
817 |
163.4 |
|
Burrus 663 |
no |
2 |
140.4 |
130.4 |
163.8 |
223.4 |
204.3 |
862.3 |
172.5 |
|
Cargill 8112 |
no |
2 |
126.2 |
120.3 |
182.1 |
199.8 |
195.8 |
824.2 |
164.8 |
|
Croplan Genetics 676RR |
no |
2 |
154.2 |
121.6 |
161.8 |
190.7 |
166.8 |
795.1 |
159.0 |
|
Dekalb DKC63-22 |
no |
2 |
132 |
131.8 |
172.9 |
211.7 |
186.7 |
835.1 |
167.0 |
|
Dekalb DKC65-25 |
no |
2 |
152.1 |
121.9 |
155.5 |
185.3 |
161.9 |
776.7 |
155.3 |
|
Fontanelle 5281 |
no |
2 |
151.1 |
114.9 |
173.3 |
210.6 |
162.8 |
812.7 |
162.5 |
|
Fontanelle 5301 |
no |
2 |
136.5 |
135.3 |
169.5 |
218.7 |
187.4 |
847.4 |
169.5 |
|
Fontanelle 5800 |
no |
2 |
155 |
145.7 |
179.2 |
214.2 |
170.4 |
864.5 |
172.9 |
|
Freedom 5555 |
no |
2 |
129.6 |
134.8 |
168.6 |
220.7 |
203.8 |
857.5 |
171.5 |
|
Freedom 5662 |
no |
2 |
134.6 |
109.6 |
163.1 |
204.6 |
187.9 |
799.8 |
160.0 |
|
Garst 8341 |
no |
2 |
144.7 |
126.5 |
154.4 |
208 |
188.9 |
822.5 |
164.5 |
|
Garst 8464IT |
no |
2 |
148.8 |
108.6 |
164.8 |
195.1 |
190.3 |
807.6 |
161.5 |
|
Golden Harvest H-9229 |
no |
2 |
131.3 |
124.9 |
185.7 |
199.3 |
194.8 |
836 |
167.2 |
|
Golden Harvest H-9345 |
no |
2 |
144.6 |
118.9 |
166.3 |
201.7 |
172.4 |
803.9 |
160.8 |
|
Golden Harvest H-9403 |
no |
2 |
135.5 |
137.2 |
186.5 |
219.4 |
195.4 |
874 |
174.8 |
|
Hawkeye Hybrids 99-786 |
no |
2 |
145.1 |
134.6 |
161.9 |
215.9 |
169.6 |
827.1 |
165.4 |
|
Hawkeye Hybrids SX76 |
no |
2 |
155.4 |
143.8 |
180.7 |
222.2 |
201.8 |
903.9 |
180.8 |
|
Kruger K-9114 |
no |
2 |
135.7 |
138 |
179.7 |
228.6 |
214 |
896 |
179.2 |
|
Kruger K-9117 |
no |
2 |
146.8 |
124.8 |
161 |
196.3 |
175.3 |
804.2 |
160.8 |
|
Kruger K-9614B |
no |
2 |
142.5 |
129.3 |
171 |
207.9 |
196.7 |
847.4 |
169.5 |
|
Kruger K-9817 |
no |
2 |
136.6 |
106 |
171.5 |
205.2 |
158.2 |
777.5 |
155.5 |
|
Kruger K-9915 |
no |
2 |
154.5 |
126 |
169.5 |
189.5 |
169.5 |
809 |
161.8 |
|
Lewis 5559 |
no |
2 |
135.4 |
119.9 |
173.1 |
220.9 |
160.9 |
810.2 |
162.0 |
|
Lewis 6420 |
no |
2 |
131.9 |
116.4 |
157.5 |
191.7 |
166.1 |
763.6 |
152.7 |
|
LG Seeds LG2606 |
no |
2 |
141.2 |
110.8 |
178.4 |
210.2 |
178.7 |
819.3 |
163.9 |
|
LG Seeds LG2677 |
no |
2 |
152.1 |
127.4 |
155 |
194.7 |
172.8 |
802 |
160.4 |
|
LG Seeds LG2696 |
no |
2 |
150.1 |
122.8 |
189 |
203.2 |
188 |
853.1 |
170.6 |
|
Merschman M-00111 |
no |
2 |
143.3 |
135.3 |
165 |
207.4 |
185.8 |
836.8 |
167.4 |
|
Merschman M-9113 |
no |
2 |
160.4 |
122.2 |
165.6 |
196.4 |
181.7 |
826.3 |
165.3 |
|
Middlekoop 1017 |
no |
2 |
155.3 |
117 |
177.2 |
226 |
193.6 |
869.1 |
173.8 |
|
Middlekoop 1214 |
no |
2 |
155.7 |
130.8 |
178.7 |
211.7 |
199.4 |
876.3 |
175.3 |
|
Middlekoop 1216 |
no |
2 |
156.8 |
111.5 |
170.1 |
201.8 |
172.1 |
812.3 |
162.5 |
|
Middlekoop 912 |
no |
2 |
145.2 |
122.2 |
170.7 |
201.9 |
182.4 |
822.4 |
164.5 |
|
NC+ 5018 |
no |
2 |
151 |
118.7 |
189.9 |
208.5 |
178.1 |
846.2 |
169.2 |
|
NC+ 5169 |
no |
2 |
128.9 |
125.1 |
172.8 |
201.6 |
182.3 |
810.7 |
162.1 |
|
NC+ 5445 |
no |
2 |
137.3 |
124.3 |
175.8 |
224.9 |
201.1 |
863.4 |
172.7 |
|
Novartis N67-T4 |
no |
2 |
135.2 |
146.3 |
175.1 |
213.9 |
188.8 |
859.3 |
171.9 |
|
Novartis N79-L3 |
no |
2 |
150.9 |
133.5 |
173.7 |
204 |
178.8 |
840.9 |
168.2 |
|
Pioneer hybrid 32R42 |
no |
2 |
151.4 |
126 |
180.4 |
216.5 |
194.1 |
868.4 |
173.7 |
|
Pioneer hybrid 33G26 |
no |
2 |
130.7 |
126 |
169.1 |
201.8 |
162.1 |
789.7 |
157.9 |
|
Rainbow Seeds 3148 |
no |
2 |
131.2 |
119.2 |
164.1 |
184.4 |
163.2 |
762.1 |
152.4 |
|
Renze 6411 |
no |
2 |
139.2 |
133.6 |
178.1 |
217 |
210.8 |
878.7 |
175.7 |
|
Renze 6421 |
no |
2 |
129.5 |
140.5 |
178.8 |
217.1 |
187.6 |
853.5 |
170.7 |
|
US Seeds US C1120 |
no |
2 |
125.9 |
125.4 |
163 |
194.4 |
169 |
777.7 |
155.5 |
|
US Seeds US C1131ND |
no |
2 |
114.5 |
112.8 |
162 |
183.3 |
182.8 |
755.4 |
151.1 |
|
US Seeds US C1139RR |
no |
2 |
145.5 |
134.2 |
167.9 |
183.2 |
189.4 |
820.2 |
164.0 |
|
US Seeds US C1151ND |
no |
2 |
114.4 |
112.5 |
145.6 |
173 |
151.6 |
697.1 |
139.4 |
|
US Seeds US C1159IT |
no |
2 |
120.3 |
130.5 |
176.8 |
185.5 |
177.8 |
790.9 |
158.2 |
|
Vigoro V5300 |
no |
2 |
132.9 |
124.1 |
183.9 |
208.3 |
196.1 |
845.3 |
169.1 |
|
Vigoro V5400 |
no |
2 |
147.7 |
126.8 |
177.9 |
209.6 |
187 |
849 |
169.8 |
|
Wilson 1762 |
no |
2 |
147.6 |
120.8 |
165.1 |
192.9 |
183.5 |
809.9 |
162.0 |
|
Wilson 2335 |
no |
2 |
157.4 |
120.5 |
185.8 |
195.4 |
191.7 |
850.8 |
170.2 |
|
Mycogen 2725 |
no |
- |
119.2 |
138.7 |
166.9 |
208.5 |
189.6 |
822.9 |
164.6 |
|
yield
total |
|
|
9019.8 |
8035 |
10919.6 |
13095.2 |
11723.4 |
52793 |
10558.6 |
|
Mean |
|
|
138.8 |
123.6 |
168.0 |
201.5 |
180.4 |
812.2 |
162.4 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Croplan Genetics 666BT/RR |
yes |
1 |
143.6 |
120.9 |
165.1 |
197.1 |
177.7 |
804.4 |
160.9 |
|
Rainbow Seeds 3100YG |
yes |
1 |
139.1 |
121.6 |
159.5 |
204.4 |
178.8 |
803.4 |
160.7 |
|
US Seeds US C1109Bt |
yes |
1 |
128 |
118.9 |
155.7 |
188 |
166.2 |
756.8 |
151.4 |
|
AgriPro 9570Bt |
yes |
2 |
143 |
141.3 |
180.7 |
222.7 |
183.1 |
870.8 |
174.2 |
|
AgriPro 9689Bt |
yes |
2 |
146.6 |
136.3 |
181.3 |
196.5 |
175.9 |
836.6 |
167.3 |
|
AgVenture AV812Bt |
yes |
2 |
143.7 |
138.4 |
161.4 |
223.3 |
187 |
853.8 |
170.8 |
|
Burrus 664Bt |
yes |
2 |
147.2 |
110.1 |
169.2 |
229 |
182.7 |
838.2 |
167.6 |
|
Cargill 7821Bt |
yes |
2 |
162.9 |
123.1 |
192 |
216.7 |
193.3 |
888 |
177.6 |
|
Cargill 7922Bt |
yes |
2 |
149.8 |
124.9 |
156.4 |
198.6 |
171.7 |
801.4 |
160.3 |
|
Croplan Genetics 762Bt/CL |
yes |
2 |
156.9 |
130.9 |
169.2 |
194.1 |
180.5 |
831.6 |
166.3 |
|
Crows C4911Bt |
yes |
2 |
138.8 |
134.3 |
168.9 |
224.9 |
182.4 |
849.3 |
169.9 |
|
Crows C687Bt |
yes |
2 |
166.2 |
115.1 |
183.7 |
203.6 |
183.9 |
852.5 |
170.5 |
|
Dekalb DK647BtY |
yes |
2 |
144.1 |
128.9 |
165.8 |
218.2 |
183.5 |
840.5 |
168.1 |
|
Fontanelle HC7747Bt |
yes |
2 |
158.7 |
125.6 |
172 |
220 |
197.7 |
874 |
174.8 |
|
Golden Harvest H-9095Bt |
yes |
2 |
134.6 |
129.7 |
164.1 |
202.7 |
190.4 |
821.5 |
164.3 |
|
Golden Harvest H-9533Bt |
yes |
2 |
153.4 |
98.8 |
174.4 |
216 |
174.6 |
817.2 |
163.4 |
|
Kruger K-116Bt |
yes |
2 |
145.7 |
108.5 |
168.8 |
206.3 |
185.6 |
814.9 |
163.0 |
|
Kruger K-9013+Bt |
yes |
2 |
140.5 |
137.9 |
166.4 |
203.1 |
176.2 |
824.1 |
164.8 |
|
Kruger K-9013Bt |
yes |
2 |
133.1 |
134.6 |
165.5 |
210.7 |
184.9 |
828.8 |
165.8 |
|
Kruger K-9014Bt |
yes |
2 |
143 |
119.9 |
173.4 |
205.6 |
177.7 |
819.6 |
163.9 |
|
Kruger K-9115Bt |
yes |
2 |
140.8 |
125.5 |
173.8 |
194.8 |
169.2 |
804.1 |
160.8 |
|
Kruger K-9614ABt |
yes |
2 |
129.8 |
131.8 |
146.1 |
205.9 |
176.6 |
790.2 |
158.0 |
|
Lewis 5909Bt |
yes |
2 |
132.5 |
122.2 |
170.5 |
212.4 |
196.5 |
834.1 |
166.8 |
|
Merschman M-9114 |
yes |
2 |
151.3 |
146.5 |
166 |
208.5 |
171.7 |
844 |
168.8 |
|
Middlekoop 813Bt |
yes |
2 |
139.3 |
107.8 |
175.1 |
220.7 |
171.3 |
814.2 |
162.8 |
|
Mycogen 2767 |
yes |
2 |
125 |
146.2 |
177.7 |
211.6 |
193.3 |
853.8 |
170.8 |
|
Mycogen 2833 |
yes |
2 |
144 |
143.6 |
183.6 |
197.5 |
178.4 |
847.1 |
169.4 |
|
Novartis N7070Bt |
yes |
2 |
156.8 |
125.9 |
162.5 |
210.4 |
196.2 |
851.8 |
170.4 |
|
Pioneer hybrid 33A14 |
yes |
2 |
131 |
105.7 |
173.2 |
205 |
200.2 |
815.1 |
163.0 |
|
Pioneer hybrid 33P67 |
yes |
2 |
132.9 |
139.5 |
190 |
224.2 |
191.2 |
877.8 |
175.6 |
|
Pioneer hybrid 34R07 |
yes |
2 |
137.3 |
124.6 |
171.5 |
200.5 |
186.4 |
820.3 |
164.1 |
|
Renze 8381Bt |
yes |
2 |
139.4 |
126.9 |
178.3 |
217 |
186.5 |
848.1 |
169.6 |
|
Triumph 1866Bt |
yes |
2 |
154.3 |
124.6 |
173.5 |
198.7 |
198.9 |
850 |
170.0 |
|
Rainbow Seeds 3175YG |
yes |
3 |
151.7 |
117.9 |
169 |
211.8 |
194.2 |
844.6 |
168.9 |
|
yield
taotal |
|
|
4885 |
4288.4 |
5804.3 |
7100.5 |
6244.4 |
28322.6 |
5664.5 |
|
Mean |
|
|
143.7 |
126.1 |
170.7 |
208.8 |
183.7 |
833.0 |
166.6 |